My Canada includes rights of Indigenous Peoples.
Love it or leave it! Peace.
Showing posts with label afn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label afn. Show all posts

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Education: Aboriginal School Boards ... imposed without consultation?

In the opinion of the National Post ..

Native chiefs would rather blame Ottawa than change

New Strahl plan has potential, if given the chance

John Ivison, National Post Published: Thursday, December 11, 2008

OTTAWA -Jamie Wilson is the 40-year-old director of education for the Opaskwayak Educational Authority, near Le Pas in Manitoba. He has three university degrees, used to be a U. S. Army Ranger and is one of the new generation of can-do aboriginal leaders who recognize that not all the failures of Canada's relationship with its First Nations can be laid at Ottawa's door.

The problem is that much of the aboriginal leadership is still in the hands of people who are so caught up in complaining about the shortcomings of the federal government that Ottawa gets blamed for everything except the weather. "It's frustrating to be caught up in it," Mr. Wilson said.

Everyone agrees that reforming aboriginal education policies is crucial, not just for the well-being of native people, but also because this country is likely to suffer chronic labour shortages when the Baby Boom generation starts to retire. And everyone, including Chuck Strahl, the Indian Affairs Minister, agrees that the current situation -- in which schools are usually run by local bands that have neither the expertise nor the resources to do it well -- is not working. Only four out of 10 aboriginal Canadians between the ages of 25 and 44 have a high school diploma, compared to nine out of 10 non-native Canadians.

But that's where the consensus ends. The government wants to roll out a plan that sees individual band schools grouped into aboriginal-run boards working with provincial governments and aboriginal organizations. This approach was pioneered in British Columbia and New Brunswick.

Yesterday, the Assembly of First Nations made clear it wants nothing to do with that idea.

Last week, unnoticed amid the mayhem on Parliament Hill, the government introduced two programs it hopes will lay the foundations for long-term reform of First Nations education: the education partnerships program and the First Nation student success program, to be financed with $268-million that was earmarked in the last budget. The partnerships initiative offers funding to First Nations that negotiate an education agreement with Ottawa and their respective provinces. The student success plan makes money available for schools that introduce a plan to improve education outcomes and then submit to learning assessments and performance measurement.

Under the new system, native-run school boards would be involved in professional development of teachers, curriculum development and centralized procurement.

Funding remains an issue. Fairness demands that the federal government fund the First Nations school system to the same level as the provinces fund non-native boards -- something that is currently not the case. Ottawa funded the average native student $6,916 in 2006-7, according to their own figures. The provincial average in that year, according to Statistics Canada, was $8,165. That masks even bigger funding gaps in provinces such as Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, where the gap is close to $3,000 a year.

Mr. Strahl hopes to sell native leaders on his plan today at a special meeting of the AFN in Ottawa. But the chiefs have already signalled their opposition. They met to discuss education at a special assembly yesterday and rejected the government's new program proposals out of hand.

Chief Tyrone McNeil, a member of the chiefs committee on education from British Columbia, said the Minister had "dictated" the new policy, without consultation with chiefs.

"Any new program needs to support current successes," he said. When it was put to him that the government believed the B. C. model was a success and this is why it was rolling it out elsewhere, he said Mr. Strahl was taking a model developed by First Nations and "forcing it on other regions."

This is typical of the myopic leadership that has helped keep Canada's aboriginal population in a vicious circle of poverty and hopelessness the chiefs claim can be broken only by more federal cash.

Many band chiefs across Canada do not want to lose control of their schools -- or, more particularly, the funding that flows to them from the federal government, which would be redirected to the new aboriginal-run education authorities under the government's scheme.

Fortunately, leaders such as Mr. Wilson are emerging -- people who argue that the situation is so dire it requires major structural reform. For Mr. Wilson, it is no longer about who controls education. "We fought hard for that control," he said, "but now we need to take responsibility."

The Strahl plan has potential, in Mr. Wilson's opinion. He would like to see some of the suggestions codified in law -- for example, a new piece of legislation that set national standards for aboriginal education in areas such as the number of school days, teacher qualification requirements and rules of school boards.

"There is a very real need for First Nations Education Act. We need to build a system," Mr. Wilson said. Crucially, he said, the argument needs to move beyond the issue of control and focus on responsibility.

"Unsuccessful schools have one thing in common--everyone blames each other. The Grade 4 teacher blames the Grade 2 teacher; the teachers blame the parents; and so on. No one takes responsibility. In successful schools, everyone takes responsibility for education outcomes," he said.

So far, the response from the chiefs has been sadly lacking. This is tragic because it is their ideas and leadership that will be the prime mover in lifting their people out of poverty, not the size of the cheque they receive from Ottawa.

jivison@nationalpost.com

Mr Ivison misses the point: Neither the "ideas and leadership" of the chiefs nor of any others in Aboriginal communities have been sought.

It is appalling that INAC is trying to unilaterally impose an education program without any input from teachers nor from parents whose children will be affected.

I get it. There are funds available to be distributed. The truth is out: Aboriginal education is underfunded in comparison to public education. That must be corrected.

The strings attached are intended to create a necessity to focus on results ... desired outcomes for students. I think there is something useful there, but it must allow for local curriculum, locally defined outcomes, locally developed assessment, local decisions about allocation of funds, etc., and somehow I don't think that's how Strahl/Harper sees it.

The unilateral imposition of a rigid program making rigid demands is self-defeating. It may be time to offer the program as an option for local choice. However, Harper is not known for his understanding of human reactions, and often shoots himself in the foot this way, as he has now yet again, with lack of consultation.

All people want is to be involved in the problem-solving planning process, rather than having so-called 'solutions' imposed from Ottawa.

g

Thursday, October 23, 2008

AFN meddling blamed for exit of commission's chairman

JOE FRIESEN

From Thursday's Globe and Mail

Harry LaForme quit the Indian Residential Schools Truth and Reconciliation Commission over interference from the Assembly of First Nations, commission counsel Owen Young, speaking on Judge LaForme's behalf, said yesterday.

Judge LaForme's position as commission chairman became untenable once it was clear that the two other commissioners, Claudette Dumont-Smith and Jane Brewin Morley, shared AFN national chief Phil Fontaine's vision of a commission centred on telling the stories of survivors, rather than a commission focused more heavily on reconciliation, Mr. Young said.

“In a nutshell, this isn't government interference, it's AFN interference,” Mr. Young said.

“Once LaForme was asserting independence it meant [Mr. Fontaine] was going to have less influence on where the commission was going.”

Mr. Fontaine responded by saying there was never any suggestion that Judge LaForme had a problem with the AFN.

He also said the settlement agreement, approved by nine judges in nine jurisdictions, doesn't allow for a chair to unilaterally determine the direction of the commission.

“The agreement is very clear about the role of the AFN: we will have a central and ongoing role in the settlement agreement,” Mr. Fontaine said.

While the AFN wanted the seven national events of the TRC to provide a showcase for survivors' stories, Judge LaForme had a different plan, Mr. Young said.

“Just to tell the stories as a stand-alone exercise is divisive,” he said. “Harry's vision was uniting and inclusive. Those are important differences. You could feel the tension between those two views and they began to be reflected in everything between the commissioners.”

In his letter of resignation to Indian Affairs Minister Chuck Strahl, Judge LaForme expressed his concern that the two other commissioners were determined to outvote him, and that they had been subject to external influence: “… the two commissioners have made it clear that their majority rule would not be grounded in Commission independence but would be shaped by the influence of some of the parties and their political representatives,” he wrote.

He added that the two commissioners had compromised commission independence, lost his confidence, betrayed his trust and worked to frustrate his pursuit of what he saw as the commission's mandate.

The question of the TRC's independence came to a head when the AFN invited the commissioners to a meeting in Ottawa on Sept. 26, where many of the parties to the settlement agreement, although not the government of Canada, would be present. Judge LaForme replied that in order to maintain his independence he couldn't attend, and he recommended that his two fellow commissioners follow suit.

Ms. Dumont-Smith, a native health worker, and Ms. Morley, a non-aboriginal lawyer, ignored his recommendation and met with the AFN and other groups. Ms. Dumont-Smith said the meeting was to provide an update on the commission's progress, which had been stalled since Aug. 26, when Judge LaForme left the group's final meeting, cancelled future meetings, and told the two commissioners to communicate with him only through intermediaries.

Ms. Dumont-Smith said Judge LaForme's absence didn't please the parties at all.

“They were very concerned that it appeared things weren't moving ahead,” she said.

She denied that the issue of a truth commission versus a reconciliation commission ever arose.

“There was never any [discussion] that we would be more on the reconciliatory side than the truth. I did and still believe that it's important we give them equal weight,” she said.

Both she and Ms. Morley have also denied ever seeking to have the commission governed by majority rule, another objection of Judge LaForme's, but have said their preference was to follow the aboriginal custom of governing by consensus.

A day after the meeting in Ottawa, Mr. Fontaine gave a speech in Montreal in which he said, according to a transcript, “we have to be careful when we talk about the impartiality of the truth commission.”

“In fact,” Mr. Fontaine said, “the commission has to be partial to the interests of the survivors, because the truth commission, this truth commission is about the survivors.”

... more perspectives ... http://rita-rosenfeld.blogspot.com/2008/10/full-disclosure.html http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/canada/story/4240618p-4883691c.html
My Canada includes rights of Indigenous Peoples.
LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT!
Peace.

Two Row Wampum Treaty

Two Row Wampum Treaty
"It is said that, each nation shall stay in their own vessels, and travel the river side by side. Further, it is said, that neither nation will try to steer the vessel of the other." This is a treaty among Indigenous Nations, and with Canada. This is the true nature of our relationships with Indigenous Nations of 'Kanata'.